So I have decided to look at CGI in more depth as it is the most common form of Special Effect used in the industry today.CGI is best for creating fictional worlds, unreal creatures or for simple enhancements on sets or actors.
A very good example of CGI use can be seen in Wolfgang Petersen's 2006 disaster remake "Poseidon". Extensive use of CGI was used to create the shots of the ship in the ocean and also the entire opening shot was created with CGI, the only Live Action element was of Josh Lucas running along the deck. (See below Link)
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bXrcTto7mzI
This shot managed to incorporate Josh Lucas running along the deck by filming him running
against a green screen. He was then matted into the CGI pallet in post production resulting in the
scene seen in the link above.
Every exterior shot of the ship was created with CGI, and in my opinion, I think that this film
showcases some of the best CGI work seen in film today.(Excluding Avatar as I have not yet
seen it, therefore I can't judge).
One of the main reasons the CGI in this film is so good is because of it's insanely huge budget
of $160,000,000. Sadly the CGI is the only good point to this film. The rest is terrible, however
I won't turn this into a review of the film. As CGI is rather expensive (But a lot cheaper than
miniatures), sometimes it is very hard to get the realism that is intended. However in Poseidon's
case, that wasn't a problem. Poseidon showcases some of the best CGI water I have ever seen
in a film. For example, take a look at the capsizing scene. The water effects are flawless.
Now if CGI was just limited to effects like this then I would certainly agree that CGI is the way
forward in films, however some films have smaller budgets, yet still rely on CGI which, due to a
cheaper company being used, the effects aren't as flawless as those seen in Poseidon.
For example, if we look at the TV movie Britannic, The CGI effects are clearly cheaply made as
the realism in them is very small.
As you can see the Green Screen effects used in this film are rather poor. The CG rendering of
the ship looks pretty good, but once the live action elements are placed in there the CG becomes
very unrealistic. For example, when the lifeboat is heading towards the rotating propellor, the water
effects look very badly matted to the live action lifeboat which destroys the dramatic reality of
the scene.
I will look at CGI further in my next post.